Parathyroid disease and parathyroid treatment is discussed by parathyroid doctors and parathyroid surgeons for parathyroid patients.

 

Section 3.

Parathyroid Disease:  Treatments to AVOID

Sensipar, Cinacalcet, with hyperparathyroidism, primary vs secondary hyperparathyroidism.
Sensipar should not be used for primary hyperparathyroidism. Sensipar (Cinacalcet) is a drug that can be used for SECONDARY hyperparathyroidism, but should NOT be used for PRIMARY hyperparathyroidism. If you are not getting kidney dialysis, then you should NOT take Sensipar. The most recent studies on Sensipar and calcium levels and parathyroid hormone are discussed.

Home Parathyroid Intro Normal Function Hyperparathyroidism Symptoms Diagnosis Osteoporosis Treatment/Surgery Mini-Surgery MIRP Mini Surgery Parathyroid Pictures Finding the Tumor Who Gets It? Do I Have Just One? What Causes It? Sestamibi Scan Surgery Cure Rates What Experts Say Frequent Questions High Blood Calcium Low Vitamin D Diagnosis-ADVANCED 10 Parathyroid Rules Sensipar Publications Parathyroid Cancer Re-Operate Hyp0parathyroid What Patients Say Table of Contents Dr. Norman About Us

 


Diagnosis and diagnosing parathyroid disease and diagnostic testing of parathyroid disease.Sensipar is a drug that can be problematic (dangerous?) when given to patients with PRIMARY hyperparathyroidism. Sensipar (Cinacalcet) is NOT approved by the FDA for treating patients with primary hyperparathyroidism. If your doctor prescribed this drug for you, you should print this page of parathyroid.com and take it to him/her. Sensipar is likely to make you feel sick, and new evidence suggests that Sensipar can make your osteoporosis worse if you take it. Most insurance companies will not pay for this drug for treating primary hyperparathyroidism... and they shouldn't! There is good evidence that taking Sensipar is worse for you than if you took nothing and simply ignored the parathyroid tumor in your neck! The pros and cons of taking Sensipar for primary hyperparathyroidism will be discussed on this page. In our opinion, there is almost never a case where a patient with primary hyperparathyroidism should be on this drug! DANGER!   Again, this drug may make you significantly worse and is not approved for patients like you!

If you are on this page of parathyroid.com because you have hyperparathyroidism and your doctor gave you a prescription for Sensipar and you came home and typed "Sensipar" into Google... then you are on the right web site... However, you may want to read about hyperparathyroidism and parathyroid disease at the beginning of this website and then come back here later. Make sure you understand that taking a pill will not make the tumor in your neck go away. Also, be careful, this is an advanced page and we will confuse you if you haven't read more about parathyroid disease on our other pages first.

Sensipar (cinicalcet) and hyperparathyroidism.Sensipar is a drug manufactured by Amgen. Sensipar is the trade name, the generic name for this drug is "Cinacalcet". Sensipar comes as a small pill in two strengths (30mg and 60mg). This drug was designed for the treatment of SECONDARY hyperparathyroidism. SECONDARY hyperparathyroidism is a disease that occurs in patients with kidney failure that are on dialysis. These patients do NOT get parathyroid tumors like patients with PRIMARY hyperparathyroidism. Patients with SECONDARY hyperparathyroidism are usually treated with a combination of medications along with dialysis to control all of the problems they have with the chemical balance of their blood (due to the lack of kidney function).Sensipar (cinicalcet) pills come in 30 mg strength.

Patients with PRIMARY hyperparathyroidism do NOT have kidney failure, and are NOT on dialysis. This entire website (parathyroid.com) is dedicated to the treatment of PRIMARY hyperparathyroidism. People with PRIMARY hyperparathyroidism have high calcium levels, high PTH levels and other issues (like kidney stones and osteoporosis) which are discussed on this website extensively. We cannot confuse primary and secondary hyperparathyroidism. Let us make this simple...if you have a parathyroid problem, and you are not on kidney dialysis, then you have PRIMARY hyperparathyroidism.

Sensipar was approved by the FDA for the treatment of SECONDARY hyperparathyroidism in March 2004. This drug works well in many patients who are on dialysis, and many thousands of patients with kidney failure are on this drug. Sensipar is NOT approved (nor does Amgen support its use) for patients who are not on kidney dialysis. Sensipar is NOT FDA approved for the treatment of PRIMARY hyperparathyroidism. This is why your insurance won't pay for it. They shouldn't! Amgen--the maker of this drug, does not say this drug can be used for primary hyperparathyroidism... and they know why --- It can make things worse!

Several studies of Sensipar were conducted in patients with PRIMARY hyperparathyroidism in the past few years (mid 2000's). Patients with primary hyperparathyroidism were given Sensipar and the doctors measured their calcium levels and PTH levels. The biggest study had a total of 40 (forty) patients getting Sensipar, while 38 got placebo (not a very big study, was it?). The trial was to last 1 year. Only 28 of the 40 patients taking Sensipar (70%) were able to stay on the drug for one year--the rest got sick and were not able to take it. Of the 28 patients that took the drug for one year, 73% had a decrease in their blood calcium levels. Only 7% of patients had a decrease in their PTH values. All the patients still had the parathyroid tumor still in their neck, and even in patients who had lower calcium levels, when the drug was stopped, their calcium and PTH levels went back up--some even higher than before. The researchers did uncover a potential problem, however, that the bones of these people may not be any better, and they may be worse. This paper can be read here: Peacock M, Bilezikian JP, et al. Cinicalcet maintains long-term normocalcemia in patients with primary hyperparathyroidism. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2005;90:135-141.

This was a well conducted study, and like other smaller studies (yep, even fewer patients), it shows that Sensipar will decrease the blood calcium in about 3/4 of patients. However, since the PTH doesn't go down in most people, it seems that the patient's bones are still exposed to excess PTH.

Our Experience With Sensipar and Primary Hyperparathyroidism.

We've put people on Sensipar who were sent to us after a failed operation somewhere else and we couldn't find their tumor (so we elected to not operate on them for a year). We have also had many patients sent to us for surgery after their doctor tried Sensipar and it made them sick, or they just continued to get worse. In June 2008 we will be presenting our data on patients with PRIMARY hyperparathyroidism who have had Sensipar for at least 1 year, some as long as 3 years. Our experience with Sensipar and primary hyperparathyroidism shows that Sensipar 1) makes a lot of people feel bad (nausea) so they can't take it, 2) in patients that can take this drug, it doesn't usually make them feel better--they still feel tired and have all the symptoms of primary hyperparathyroidism, 3) their calcium does come down, some more than others, but all are intermittent, 4) most people have a WORSENING of their osteoporosis. Our experiences with this drug are very poor, and we have written the FDA and Amgen to make them aware of our findings... the abstract of our findings which will be presented at the biggest endocrine meeting of the year is here:

Being Presented at Endocrine Society 08. San Francisco, CA. June, 2008.

Cinacalcet (Sensipar) provides no measurable clinical benefits for patients with primary hyperparathyroidism and significantly accelerates bone loss with prolonged use.

James Norman, MD, FACS, FACE, and Doug Politz, MD, FACS.
Norman Parathyroid Clinic.

Introduction: Cinacalcet (Sensipar) has been shown to decrease calcium levels in patients with primary hyperparathyroidism (PHPT) in several small trials, however no other endpoints have been studied and long-term effects are not known.

Methods: 90 patients began Cinacalcet as an alternative to surgery for PHPT. Patients filled out a symptom questionnaire specific for PHPT. All had bone density DEXA scans before treatment and annually. All patients were followed as long as the drug was tolerated or until complications arose, at which time all underwent minimally invasive parathyroidectomy. Starting dose was 30mg/d and increased to 60 to 90mg/d as necessary. Serum calcium and PTH levels were studied at 3-4 month intervals. Symptom resolution was tracked.

Results: Women comprised 73% while 27% were men. The average age was 62 (range 19-90). Prior to treatment, serum calcium levels averaged 11.7 (range 11.0 - 15.1) and PTH averaged 126 (range 88-815). 93% had 2 or more classic parathyroid symptoms (average 5.3 symptoms, range 0-9). Cinacalcet had to be discontinued in 19 patients (21%) within 3 months because of nausea and vomiting. The remainder (n=71) were treated from 8 to 34 months. Calcium and/or PTH levels dropped in 98% of patients taking Cinacalcet, but this was intermittent in all patients, none had consistently normal calcium levels. Despite decreases in calcium, only 5 (7%) had any relief from their symptoms (p=0.08), and 11 (15.5%) said they actually felt worse (p<0.05). 23 patients had Cinacalcet for >1.5 years, all of which showed decreases in bone density. 19 of the 23 (83%) had significant reductions in bone density of 1.5 to 2.9 standard deviations below their starting point (p<0.01). Those on the drug longer had the most loss of bone density (R=0.83) losing density faster than 500 cohort PHPT patients with no therapy (p<0.05). All patients underwent mini, outpatient surgery and were cured. 96% had partial or complete resolution of symptoms within 2 months of surgery (p< 0.001).

Conclusion: Although Cinacalcet will cause intermittent reductions in serum calcium in patients with PHPT, this provides symptom relief in almost none. Prolonged use of Cinacalcet is associated with significant bone loss that is accelerated over bone loss seen in untreated PHPT patients. There appears to be no role for Cinacalcet in the treatment of PHPT; patients are better off with no treatment. Surgery remains the best choice for these patients.

The full manuscript of this study will be published later in 2008.

Sensipar and Primary Hyperparathyroidism... What is the Bottom Line?

The bottom line is this: primary hyperparathyroidism is caused by a tumor of one (or uncommonly, two) parathyroid glands. Taking a pill every day will not remove the tumor. Taking a pill every day may actually accelerate the formation of osteoporosis--thus this drug does not appear to be a way to "avoid" parathyroid surgery. If your doctor thinks you can "avoid" parathyroid surgery, or "delay" parathyroid surgery by taking a pill every day... then print this and take it to him/her. There is NO medical evidence ANYWHERE that suggests taking Sensipar will help you avoid surgery. In fact, all of the evidence is that 1/3 of you can't tolerate the drug because it will make you sick, and most of you will get a dramatic worsening of your bones. And THEN, you will get surgery to get the tumor out.

This drug will cost you between $620 and $1250 per month in the US. Most insurances will not pay it... and they should not. It is in your best interest to find an excellent parathyroid surgeon and get the parathyroid tumor removed. It can be done in less than 20 minutes by some experts... then get on with your life.                Sensipar, Sensipar-HCL. Cinicalcet, Sensipar-Cinicalcet, Cinacalcet, Cinacalcet-Sensipar, Cinacalcet-HCL, Cinicalcet-HCL. 

This page was last updated 04/06/2008

 

Home ] Parathyroid Intro ] Normal Function ] Hyperparathyroidism ] Symptoms ] Diagnosis ] Osteoporosis ] Treatment/Surgery ] Mini-Surgery ] MIRP Mini Surgery ] Parathyroid Pictures ] Finding the Tumor ] Who Gets It? ] Do I Have Just One? ] What Causes It? ] Sestamibi Scan ] Surgery Cure Rates ] What Experts Say ] Frequent Questions ] High Blood Calcium ] Low Vitamin D ] Diagnosis-ADVANCED ] 10 Parathyroid Rules ] [ Sensipar ] Publications ] Parathyroid Cancer ] Re-Operate ] Hyp0parathyroid ] What Patients Say ] Table of Contents ] Dr. Norman ] About Us ]

Parathyroid.com is an educational service of the Norman Parathyroid Clinic, the world's only parathyroid-exclusive clinic, 
consulting on over 3500 parathyroid patients and performing approximately 1800 mini-parathyroid operations annually.
Patients: Please copy, print, send, and link-to as you like!

Copyright © 1996-2008 Norman Endocrine Surgery Clinic
All Rights Reserved, corporate re-printing requires written approval.

Disclaimer